Molecular Geometry & Bonding
what the shape decides
The collection

Every essay — page 23

Page 23 of 36, continuing through the fields in the same order.

Orbitals Where the atoms go Bonding models What symmetry decides Beyond the octet What a spectrum settles When the molecule does not stop What the shape is for What is taught wrongly Series Named objects Orbitals Refutations Search

When the molecule does not stop

A chain of two hundred atoms is a molecule and behaves like a solid. Bands, gaps, metals, defects and surfaces, every one of them out of a finite matrix — and a clear account of what that route cannot reach.

Where the two halves of an alloy come apart. The gap at the centre of a binary alloy's band against the contrast between its two components, for a chain of 2048 sites arranged three ways. The ordered arrangement's gap is exactly twice the contrast and opens at once; the segregated one's is exactly the contrast less the band width and opens at 2; and the random one, which has no closed form, opens a little before the segregated one and stays a little wider. Below the openings the curves sit at one level spacing rather than at zero, which is what a finite chain has instead of a gap.

Two bands, if the chain is short enough

Take a chain, raise half its sites and lower the other half, and ask when the band comes apart into two. The ordered arrangement splits at once, the segregated one at a contrast equal to the band width, and the random one splits earlier than either — and then closes again as the chain is made longer, because a long chain contains a long run of like atoms and a long run is a narrow sub-band.

8 figures Every arrangement, and the winner is not the one with the most unlike bonds. All 1820 ways of raising 4 of 16 sites on a wrapped square net, at a contrast of 4, each placed by its count of unlike bonds against the binding it gives. The best arrangement has 12 unlike bonds where 16 is available, and it binds at 1.103953 against 1.080031 for the best of those that do have the most. The count and the spectrum are two different orderings.

The arrangement a count cannot pick

Three arrangements of one composition came out ordered by their count of unlike bonds, which looked like a rule. Enumerating every arrangement instead of three shows it is not one: it holds at every composition on a square net at a small contrast, fails at four of them at a large contrast, and fails on a triangular net at any contrast at all.

7 figures The chain distorts hardest where it stops. The alternation of each bond along a relaxed chain of 64, at four elastic constants, with the bulk value of each drawn as a dashed line. Every chain alternates more at its end than in its middle — by 1.21 times at the stiffest and 3.15 at the softest — and the excess dies away over a handful of bonds. The uniform alternation usually assumed is the flat part of these curves.

The chain distorts hardest where it stops

Holding the alternation uniform is what made the end energy a clean constant, and it is the one assumption the end-energy calculation had to make. Letting every bond find its own value shows the distortion is largest at the end and decays inwards over a measurable length — one and a half bonds in a strongly dimerised chain, five in a weak one.

7 figures Two curves that cross, and two that do not. Every pair of parameters that reproduces one measured number, for three numbers, with the true system marked at Δ = 12 and t⊥ = 0.06. The lower band's shape is a function of the ratio of the two, so its curve is a straight line through the origin; the excess gap is a function of the coupling squared over the separation, so its curve bends. The two cross at one point. The upper band's shape draws a line almost on top of the first, because it is a function of the same ratio — a second measurement lying along the first fixes nothing the first had not already fixed.

Two ways of being second order

A band's shape and a band's gap are both second order in the coupling that mixes two bands, which sounds like a reason to measure only one of them. They are second order in different ways — one goes as the square of the ratio and the other as the square over the separation — and that single difference of one power is what turns a curve of possible answers into a point.

9 figures A state in the gap is a particle in a box the alloy happened to make. The participation ratio of the 40 levels nearest the gap centre, over 5 chains of 400 sites, against the length of the run of like sites each one sits on. The line is 2(L+1)/3, the participation ratio of the ground state of an isolated chain of L sites, with nothing fitted. 38 of 40 lie on it to within 3.1 per cent. The ones above it are states shared between two runs close enough to talk, which is a defect band beginning.

A particle in a box the alloy made

A random alloy's gap is set by the longest run of like sites. What sits at the edge of that gap turns out to be the simplest state in quantum mechanics: a particle in a box of L sites, occupying 2(L+1)/3 of them, to within three per cent and with nothing fitted — except for the two states in forty that found a second run to share.

7 figures Two lengths off the same chains, and only one of them has an exponent. The length an end's influence reaches into a chain of 320, against the gap the bulk has opened, over ten elastic constants and a factor of twenty in the gap. Fitted over the first twelve bonds — as a short-window fit does — the exponent is -0.476. Taken from the local decay rate extrapolated to a bond infinitely far from the end, it is -1.029, and every neighbouring pair of points gives between -1.06 and -0.91. The argument says −1. The two lines are the same ten profiles read two ways.

A decay that keeps slowing down

A healing length fitted over the first twelve bonds of each relaxed chain goes as the gap to the power −0.60, against an argument that says −1. A fitted exponent can belong to its window, and this one does — but not because the window is too short for the chain. The profile is not an exponential at all, so there is no single length for an exponent to be of.

7 figures Where the coupling overtakes the spacing. Two quantities that both depend on the chain length, for runs of 6. The coupling is the splitting of the closest pair of runs, which rises as the chain grows because a longer chain brings some pair closer together. The spacing is the mean separation of the gap levels in energy, which falls as the chain grows because there are more of them. They cross at 8,675 sites, and a set of levels coupled more strongly than they are spaced is a band.

The length at which levels become a band

Two runs of low sites share a state when they are close enough, and the splitting falls exponentially over two sites. A longer chain brings some pair closer while spreading its levels thinner, so the two quantities run against each other and cross — at about a thousand sites for runs of four and eighty thousand for runs of eight. Chains of four hundred sites are far below that, which is why every gap state on them is a box.

6 figures Two bands, square below, triangular above. The 128 levels of a structure carrying two orbitals on every one of its 64 sites, where the lower orbitals hop on a square net and the upper ones on a triangular net, separated by 12 and coupled at 0.06. The two bands have different widths and different shapes before anything mixes, which is the situation a single net cannot construct. Every level here is also reproduced by a two-by-two problem, one per mode, to 3e-13.

The constant that belonged to one net

Divide one second-order departure by another and the coupling cancels, leaving one constant times the gap — which reads as arithmetic. It was arithmetic about a square net. On a triangular one — the same graph for both bands, nothing else changed — the quotient drifts by a hundred and twenty-eight per cent.

6 figures How many places a local search can stop. The number of distinct arrangements a steepest-ascent search settles at, for each net and contrast, with the fraction of starts reaching the best of them written beside it. 16 sites, contrast 1: 2 from 200 starts, best reached 67 per cent of the time; 16 sites, contrast 4: 2 from 200 starts, best reached 59 per cent of the time; 36 sites, contrast 1: 4 from 20 starts, best reached 80 per cent of the time; 36 sites, contrast 4: 12 from 20 starts, best reached 10 per cent of the time. The larger net at the larger contrast is a different kind of landscape.

Twelve basins where there were two

Sixteen sites can be searched exhaustively and thirty-six cannot, so the only instrument available past about twenty sites is a local search — and how much weaker it is has never been measured against the answer on a net where both can be run. On sixteen it is barely weaker at all. On thirty-six it fails nine starts in ten, and the arrangement it is beaten by has fewer unlike bonds than the one it starts from.

6 figures The coupling at the closest pair, and at the typical one. For runs of four to eight low sites at half concentration: the splitting between two runs one site apart, which is the largest coupling any chain can produce, and the splitting at the separation two runs typically have. Both on a logarithmic axis spanning 173 decades. A band width taken from the second is not a small number; it is not a number.

A band that is a hundred and seventy decades of nothing

The chain length at which a defect's levels become a band can be located by asking when the coupling between the closest pair exceeds the level spacing. A band also has a width, and a width is set by the typical coupling rather than the closest one. For runs of eight at half concentration those two numbers differ by a hundred and seventy-three orders of magnitude.

6 figures Seven nets, and the one column that sorts them. Every wrapped net here, with its dimension, coordination, third moment and band shape, beside the exponent the coupled-band measurement returns for it. The 4 nets whose third moment vanishes all give an exponent within 0.03 of −2 and a quotient constant to a fiftieth of a per cent; the 3 that do not all give one near −1 and no constant at all. Dimension does not sort them and neither does coordination — each takes values in both groups.

Seven points that looked like a switch

A constant belongs to a square net and not to a triangular one, which points at the coupling graph. Seven wrapped nets say which property of it: the third moment, and neither the dimension nor the coordination. They also say it is a switch — and made continuous, it is a crossover that every one of the seven sits twenty-five times past.

6 figures Nine combinations, and the column that sorts them is not the bands'. Two bands and a coupling, varied separately. The composite graph's third moment splits into triangles that lie inside a band and triangles that use two coupling bonds, and only the second sorts the table: every row with no gap-crossing triangle gives an exponent near −2 and a nearly constant quotient, whatever its bands are made of. Triangular bands carrying an intra-band moment of 7.296 behave exactly like square ones when the coupling is a matching.

The triangles that were never in the bands

A switch in how a gap scales is usually attributed to a band's third moment, and the attribution cannot be tested while the coupling runs along one of the bands. Separated, the bands turn out to decide nothing. Two triangular bands coupled along a matching — which cannot close a triangle across the gap — behave exactly like square ones.

6 figures