Molecular Geometry & Bonding
what the shape decides
Theme

The thread: Symmetry settles it

Whether a molecule can have a dipole, or be chiral, or show a particular spectral line, follows from its point group alone — with no reference to what the bonds are made of.
HHHNC3vprincipal axis C33 mirror planesno inversion centremay be polarcannot be chiralgroup recovered from the coordinates4 atoms What symmetry decides

Point groups from coordinates

A molecule's symmetry is not a label to be looked up. It is decidable from the atom positions by searching for the operations that permute them, and the search either finds an operation or it does not.

 axial — 2 sitesneighbours at 90°, 90°, 90°, 180°equatorial — 3 sitesneighbours at 90°, 90°, 120°, 120°the two are not equivalentneighbour angles measured, not assumed5 sites Where the atoms go

Five sites are not alike

Every other common arrangement has one or two distinct angles. Five has three, because two of its positions are on an axis and three are round an equator — and a molecule built that way does something about it.

 1s · 2pxS = 0 exactlycomputed -9.6e-17 — arithmetic noiseseparation 2.8 bohrcontours at 50% of each densitythe contributions cancel in pairs, so the integral vanishesone electron Bonding models

Exactly zero

Where symmetry forbids an interaction the overlap is not small. It is zero — and computing it and finding arithmetic noise is a different kind of statement from computing it and finding a small number.

 moleculegroupmay be polarmay be chiralwaterC2vyesno2 σcarbon dioxideD∞hnonohas iammoniaC3vyesno3 σmethaneTdnono6 σboron trifluorideD3hnono4 σhydrogen peroxideC2yesyes—bromochlorofluoromethaneC1yesyes—both columns derived from the symbol, not from the bonds What symmetry decides

Symmetry forbids a dipole

Whether a molecule can have a dipole moment follows from its point group alone. The usual argument — adding up bond vectors — gets the right answer for easy cases by a route that does not generalise.

 HHCCHCCHCCHHD6hprincipal axis C67 mirror planeshas an inversion centrecannot be polarcannot be chiralgroup recovered from the coordinates12 atoms Beyond the octet

Delocalisation

Benzene does not alternate between two structures. It has one structure, and the two Kekulé forms are basis functions in a description of it — which is a different and much less exciting claim than the one usually made.

 BrClCHFC1no rotation axis0 mirror planesno inversion centremay be polarmay be chiralgroup recovered from the coordinates5 atoms What symmetry decides

Chirality is a symmetry statement

A molecule is chiral when its group contains no improper operation at all. The four-different-groups rule is a useful special case that misses molecules with no stereocentre and wrongly condemns some that have several.

 moleculegroupmay be polarmay be chiralwaterC2vyesno2 σcarbon dioxideD∞hnonohas iammoniaC3vyesno3 σmethaneTdnono6 σboron trifluorideD3hnono4 σhydrogen peroxideC2yesyes—bromochlorofluoromethaneC1yesyes—both columns derived from the symbol, not from the bonds What is taught wrongly

The dipole is not a sum of bonds

Adding bond dipoles as vectors gets the easy cases right and rests on a quantity with several incompatible definitions. The symmetry argument is exact, needs no electronegativities, and says when the answer must be zero.

All themes