Every essay — page 45
Orbitals Where the atoms go Bonding models What symmetry decides Beyond the octet What a spectrum settles When the molecule does not stop What the shape is for What is taught wrongly Series Named objects Orbitals Refutations Search
What is taught wrongly
The explanations that are confident, memorable and false — stated fairly and then tested against a calculation rather than an opinion.
A repulsion the proton does not have
Asked whether moving one whole electron pays, eight bonds with measured dipoles came out six right and two wrong: hydrogen fluoride and hydrogen chloride, both predicted ionic. The proposed fix was the repulsion between the two ions' closed shells. Add it the way an ion pair demands of itself, and the score becomes eight of eight — but the repulsion that does it is largest for the shortest bonds, and the shortest bonds are the ones whose cation is a bare proton with no shell at all. The term a proton really has, penetration into the anion's cloud, undoes hydrogen chloride and not hydrogen fluoride. And the measured bond energies demand a repulsion only for the three alkali halides.
Two measurements leave nothing to fit
A bond pictured as a mixture of its ionic and covalent arrangements has two unknowns — the coupling between them and the covalent arrangement's own energy — and a dipole fixes only one. Add the bond energy and the two-state problem inverts exactly, with no parameter left. The covalent arrangement it returns can then be held against something it never saw: Pauling's mean of the two homonuclear bond energies. For hydrogen chloride, bromide and iodide it lands on that mean to within three and a half per cent, and chlorine monofluoride within nine. Hydrogen fluoride lands 68 per cent above it. And the couplings rise and fall with length rather than falling — hydrogen fluoride's, on the shortest bond, is the smallest.
The limit was two chains at once
At infinite repulsion every removal line of a half-filled chain is a hole's standing wave read against the spin chain the hole moves through, and every hole level carries exactly half an electron. On the chain of four that makes the contrast's limit (20 + 5√3 + √15)/(20 + 5√3 − √15) = 1.3124978 — not 21/16, which it misses in the sixth figure. On chains of eight and twelve, which no exact spectrum had reached, the limit is 1.0458 and 1.0195, and an energy that vanishes in the limit decides it.
The worst case measured the reference
Every score on the transferability square carries one correlation correction, fitted at a repulsion of eight and no site energy. Carried instead from seven other systems — three beside the band where the mean field's start misses, four on it — the polarisation's worst error ratio on the lowest mean field runs from 9.7 to 213, where fixing the start had moved it only from 48 to 14.7. Its median stays between 1.21 and 1.55. A worst ratio divides by the smallest comparable error it can find, and the reference decides where that is. And a reference fitted to the wrong solution passes the census at 2.05 while every system's error is above a half.
A constant ties the polarisation
Every score on the transferability square moved with where the borrowed correction was fitted, and an absolute score was the natural repair. It repairs nothing, because a change of reference slides every error along one straight line. The only thing a diagnostic can be asked to predict without a reference is the correlation energy itself, and asked that, the polarisation fails more plainly than any ratio showed: twenty-seven systems read exactly zero, including both the system with the least correlation on the grid and the one with the most. No function of it can beat a single constant, and a second reference does not help.
Two readings separate the square only where they do not fold
Reading two cheap diagnostics together cut the floor that no composite can beat tenfold on eighty-one systems, and the warning was that two dimensions sampled that thinly leave most cells empty. Refined to 1,089 systems, four of the six pairs climb back to what one reading or a single constant gives. Two stay near 0.03, and halving the tolerance tells them apart from the rest: their floor shrinks with it, because the systems that set it are neighbours. The others fold the square, and no density removes a fold.
A reference at the worst miss made the worst miss worse
A composite that borrows the correlation energy of the nearest reference system missed worst on a stretch of the transferability square where the correlation energy changes fast, and the hope was that a handful of references placed there would bring the worst miss down to the median's. The stretch is the line where the site energy equals the repulsion: all twenty-one misses above 0.08 lie near it. But no rule that can be run without knowing every answer gets the worst lower than 0.060, a rule that does know every answer needs 480 of the 1,008 systems to reach the median, and its very first placement raises the worst miss from 0.166 to 0.200.
The lookup was the problem, not the references
A composite that borrows the nearest reference system's correlation energy missed the transferability square's crossover line by up to 0.166, and no placement of extra references a calculation could run brought that below 0.060. Changing the lookup instead does better with no new references at all: a least-squares plane through the six nearest gives a worst miss of 0.088 and a median of 0.0050, against 0.166 and 0.013. A weighted average of three, the obvious smoother, makes the worst miss worse. Neither makes a reference harmless — the plane's own best placement raises its worst miss thirty times in 128 steps, twice to nearly four — but the spread among a system's three nearest references, known in advance, flags seventeen of the twenty-one worst misses among its top fifty.
Leverage catches the spikes and none of the rises
A least-squares plane through a system's six nearest references was the best lookup the transferability square had found, and its own greedy placement twice extrapolated to misses of 3.99 and 2.05. Both are visible before any answer is known: the plane's leverage at the system, the variance factor of the value it returns, is 6,706 and 2,172 there and never above 1.88 on any held-out system of the coarse references. A guard anywhere between 2 and 100 removes both spikes and changes nothing else. It does not make the plane monotone. The guarded plane's worst miss still rises thirty-two times in 128 placements, and every one of those rises — and every one of the unguarded plane's thirty — happens at a system whose six neighbours have just gained the reference placed.