The collection

Every essay — page 39

Page 39 of 42, continuing through the fields in the same order.

Orbitals Where the atoms go Bonding models What symmetry decides Beyond the octet What a spectrum settles When the molecule does not stop What the shape is for What is taught wrongly Series Named objects Orbitals Refutations Search

What is taught wrongly

The explanations that are confident, memorable and false — stated fairly and then tested against a calculation rather than an opinion.

6 fitted force fields. Every valence force field fitted here, ordered by the size of its bond stretching constant, with the stretching frequencies of the molecule beside it. The two orders are not the same, which is the whole of what separates a force constant from a frequency. The last two columns say how many constants were fitted to how many observed frequencies, and a field with as many of the first as the molecule has distinct frequencies fits exactly and reports nothing.

The frequency is not the bond strength

Sulfur dioxide's S–O force constant is larger than water's O–H constant, and its stretching bands sit at a third of the frequency. A vibrational frequency carries a mass as well as a force, and the two cannot be separated by looking at a spectrum.

5 figures

methane: 2 valence bands. The measured valence photoelectron bands of methane, each labelled with the symmetry species of the orbital it comes from, and beside them the species the valence basis spans — the central atom's s and p functions and one s on each ligand, reduced in the molecule's own group. A band carrying a species the reduction does not produce would stop this figure being drawn.

What a photoelectron spectrum measures

The bands of a photoelectron spectrum are routinely read off as orbital energies. They are ionisation energies, which is a different quantity — and the identification rests on two errors of about an electronvolt each that happen to have opposite signs.

7 figures

60 electrons in 60 levels. The density of states of a ring of 60, drawn with the energy up the page, and the 60 electrons filled in from the bottom. Where the filling stops is what decides whether the system has cheap excitations.

A half-filled band is not always a metal

Every band picture rests on an approximation that a whole class of materials refuses — each electron moving in an average field, never seeing another one individually. Where the repulsion is strong enough, a half-filled band describes an insulator, and no amount of care with the band fixes it.

5 figures

The gap against size: uniform against δ = 0.15. The HOMO–LUMO gap of a half-filled chain plotted against the number of sites, on log axes, for a uniform chain and for one whose bonds alternate. The uniform sequence falls without limit; the alternating one settles at four times the alternation.

A band gap is not a bond energy

Silicon's gap is 1.1 electronvolts and its Si–Si bond is 2.3. Both are quoted in the same units, both describe the same material, and neither is convertible into the other — one is the cost of promoting an electron and the other is the cost of taking two atoms apart.

5 figures

What orders the spectrochemical series, and what does not. Nine ligands' measured octahedral splittings, plotted against charge and against the π parameter that says whether the ligand donates or accepts π density. Charge puts 3 of 20 mixed-charge pairs in the order it predicts; the π parameter puts 35 of 35 in order.

The spectrochemical series is not electrostatics

Ligands can be put in order by how hard they split a d shell, and the order is highly reproducible. It is not the order of charge — three of twenty mixed-charge pairs come out the way a point-charge model predicts, which is worse than tossing a coin — and the two ligands at the strong end are electrically neutral.

8 figures

Why d⁸ is square planar and nothing else is. The ligand field energy a square plane buys over a tetrahedron, for every d^n, each geometry in its own ground state. The maximum is at d⁸ (1.73 in units of eσ), it is exactly zero for an empty shell and a full one, and d⁸ is one of only two fillings where the plane is diamagnetic and the tetrahedron is not.

VSEPR does not reach a transition metal

Four ligands minimising their repulsion give a tetrahedron, whatever the metal. Half the four-coordinate complexes of the platinum group are square planar, which has larger repulsion, and the term that overrules it is largest at d⁸ and exactly zero at d⁰ and d¹⁰ — which is where the repulsion rule works again.

7 figures

Bonds the scales disagree about. For each bond, which atom each scale calls the more electronegative. Every row is a bond whose polarity would be drawn in opposite directions depending on which of these four tables in common use was consulted: Pauling, Mulliken, Allred–Rochow, Allen.

A ranking is not a difference

Four electronegativity scales agree about order to a Spearman coefficient of 0.99 and disagree about size by a factor of sixty-two. Put each on its own range and the O–H bond is 39 per cent of the way across on three scales and 4.5 on the fourth.

7 figures

The energy is the last thing a wrong wavefunction gets wrong. Two errors against the error in the wavefunction, on log axes, for a chain of 2 at U = 4t. The energy's line has slope 2.00 and the double occupancy's has slope 1.01: the first is second order in the error and the second is first order. So the two lines diverge as the wavefunction improves, and the energy stops being evidence about anything else long before it stops improving.

A better energy is not a better answer

The variational principle makes the energy a one-way test: lower is closer. It also makes the energy the least sensitive thing a wavefunction gets wrong — second order in the error where every other property is first — so the two diverge without limit as a calculation improves.

5 figures

Three answers to one question. The energy to remove an electron from a half-filled four-site system, computed three ways against the repulsion: exactly, by solving a self-consistent field twice — once for the molecule and once for the ion — and by reading the highest occupied orbital energy straight off the molecule, which is Koopmans' theorem. All three agree exactly at zero repulsion. The theorem always sits above the two-calculation answer, because letting the ion relax can only lower it; the exact answer sits above both, because the molecule is more correlated than its ion. The two errors have opposite signs and do not cancel: the residue grows to 6.03.

Koopmans' theorem is exact for nothing

Reading an ionisation energy off an orbital energy neglects two things that pull in opposite directions, and the cancellation between them is quoted as the reason it works. Compute all three energies in a model where the exact answer is available and the cancellation is real, partial, and gone by the time the repulsion is twice the hopping.

5 figures $Five sixths of the bonds, nine tenths of the binding. What a site in the outer layer of an open block keeps, measured three ways: the fraction of its bonds, the fraction the second-moment rule predicts of its binding, and the fraction the calculation gives. The last two agree and the first does not.$

A surface is not a count of broken bonds

Cut a crystal and every atom in the new face has lost one of its six neighbours. The standard estimate follows immediately: a surface costs one sixth of the cohesive energy per atom exposed. Computed, it costs a little over half that — the atom keeps 91.2 per cent of its binding while keeping only 83.3 per cent of its bonds, because the bonds that survive get stronger when their competitors are removed.

5 figures

Where two bands lie, as their centres are pulled apart. The σ band and the π band of a two-orbital chain, drawn as the intervals they occupy, against the difference in site energy between the two orbitals. Below a difference of 3 the two intervals overlap and the filled-band count stops deciding anything.

A full band is not an insulator

Two electrons per atom, two orbitals per atom, and the lower set exactly full: the count says insulator, and magnesium is a metal. The count is not wrong about the count. What it assumes is that the two sets of levels occupy separate ranges of energy, and whether they do is a comparison of four numbers that has nothing to do with how many electrons there are.

8 figures

H³⁵Cl: the well, its states and their averages. The Morse potential built from H³⁵Cl's measured vibrational constants, with the lowest four states drawn at their computed energies and the average separation of each marked. Every average lies to the right of the minimum, because the well is not symmetric — and they move outward as the state rises.

The bond length that depends on the isotope

Hydrogen chloride and deuterium chloride have the same potential energy curve, and their measured equilibrium lengths agree to three hundredths of a milliångström. Their average bond lengths differ by 4.34 mÅ — a hundred times more — because a lighter atom explores more of a well that is not symmetric.

8 figures