Molecular Geometry & Bonding
what the shape decides
Concept

Radial distribution — where it appears

The probability of finding an electron in a shell at a given distance, which is the squared wavefunction times the area of the shell. Its maximum is not where the wavefunction is largest, and the two are routinely confused.

Named by 10 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The radial function of 1s. The radial part of the wavefunction, which changes sign at each node, and the radial distribution, which is the probability of finding the electron in a shell at that radius. The second vanishes at the nucleus and the first does not.

Where the electron is

The wavefunction is largest at the nucleus, the electron is most likely to be found a bohr out, and the ninety-per-cent contour is at 2.66. Three numbers, all correct, all answering different questions.

orbitals · Orbital The radial function of 3s. The radial part of the wavefunction, which changes sign at each node, and the radial distribution, which is the probability of finding the electron in a shell at that radius. The second vanishes at the nucleus and the first does not.

The radial distribution across the periodic table

A 4s orbital is bigger than a 3d by every measure of size except the one that decides which fills first. Penetration is a feature of a small inner peak, and the periodic table's shape depends on it.

orbitals · Orbital 4s and 3d from Sc to Zn. The mean radius of the 4s and 3d orbitals across the elements Sc to Zn, at the nuclear charge each shell actually feels. The screening is Slater's, which is fitted; the radius that follows from it is the closed form for a hydrogen-like orbital, which is not.

What an electron actually feels

A 3d orbital is less than half the size of the 4s beside it and fills second anyway. The charge an electron feels is not the nuclear charge, the correction is a fit rather than a derivation, and the two facts together explain the shape of the periodic table.

orbitals · Orbital Four measures of size for 6 orbitals. The most probable radius, the mean radius, the root-mean-square radius and the radius of the sphere holding ninety per cent of the density, for 1s, 2s, 2pz, 3s, 3dz2, 4s. All four are computed from the same radial function, all four are correct, and they are not the same number.

How big is an orbital

Four measures of size, all computed from the same radial function, all correct, and spanning a factor of two and a half for a 1s orbital. The one that governs chemistry is a fifth, and it is not a measure of size at all.

orbitals · Contour 1s, 2s, 2pz, 3s, 3dz2, 4s at one level and at one fraction. The orbitals 1s, 2s, 2pz, 3s, 3dz2, 4s, each with the contour level that encloses 90 per cent of its own density, and beside it what each one encloses when they are instead all drawn at 1s's level. The first column is a set of pictures that can be compared; the second is what a plate drawn at a single contour value actually shows. Contours drawn: 1s at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 3.94e-2; 2s at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 7.40e-3; 2pz at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 9.48e-3; 3s at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 2.64e-3; 3dz2 at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 3.60e-3; 4s at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 1.24e-3.

One level is not one comparison

A plate of orbitals drawn at a single contour value looks like a comparison and is not one. At the level that encloses ninety per cent of a 1s, a 2s encloses four per cent, a 3s under one, and a 3d has no surface at all — its wavefunction never reaches that value anywhere in space.

orbitals · Contour 2s and 2p from B to Ne. The mean radius of the 2s and 2p orbitals across the elements B to Ne, at the nuclear charge each shell actually feels. The screening is Slater's, which is fitted; the radius that follows from it is the closed form for a hydrogen-like orbital, which is not.

What the screening model cannot see

Slater's rules put the 2s and the 2p in one group, so they give both orbitals exactly the same effective nuclear charge at every element from boron to neon. The two are separated by several electronvolts in all six, and the model has no term that could produce it.

orbitals · Orbital One isovalue, many fractions — and one fraction, many isovalues. What each of 4 conventional isovalues encloses, for 7 orbitals of hydrogen, and in the last column the level each one needs to enclose 90 per cent. At 0.02 atomic units the fractions run from 0.4 to 96.2 per cent, and the levels in the last column differ by a factor of 32. A plate of orbitals drawn at one value is not a comparison of sizes. Contours drawn: 1s at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 3.94e-2; 2s at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 7.40e-3; 2pz at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 9.48e-3; 3s at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 2.64e-3; 3pz at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 3.03e-3; 3dz2 at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 3.60e-3; 4s at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 1.24e-3.

The isovalue nobody chose

Every program that draws an orbital asks for a number, and almost every user accepts the default. At 0.02 atomic units that default encloses 96 per cent of hydrogen's 1s, 52 per cent of its 2s and four tenths of one per cent of its 4s — three pictures drawn to one rule, meaning three completely different things.

orbitals · Contour The surface-honest curve and the page-honest curve. The 2pz orbital in its xz plane, drawn twice. The outer curve is the contour whose SURFACE encloses 90.0 per cent of the density in space — the claim every orbital figure here makes — and in this plane it encloses 96.7 per cent. The inner curve is the one that encloses 90 per cent in the plane, which is what a reader looking at a flat picture would take the caption to mean. The two levels differ by a factor of 1.87 and the curves differ visibly; the caption does not. Contours drawn: 2pz at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 9.48e-3.

A slice is not the surface

The page is flat, so every printed orbital is a slice through a contour rather than the contour itself — and a curve that leaves a tenth of the density outside it in space leaves about a thirtieth outside it on the page. Both claims are true of the same picture and only one of them is ever stated.

orbitals · Contour Where the electron is, and how fast it is going. The radial distribution in position on the left and in momentum on the right, for the same orbitals. The two run opposite ways: the 1s is the most compact in space and the widest in momentum, and every excited orbital that spreads out in one narrows in the other. Both are normalised, both are the same function, and neither is more fundamental than the other — the transform loses nothing and adds nothing.

The orbital in momentum space

Every orbital has a second picture as complete as the first and almost never drawn. Nothing is added by taking it — it is the same function in the other variable — but the uncertainty product falls out of it, and the functions quantum chemistry is built from turn out to be the only ones that attain the bound.

orbitals · Orbital The fraction a table encloses is not one number. For each ion, the fraction of its own electron density that lies inside its tabulated radius. Along each isoelectronic series the answer runs over eight percentage points, where three neutral atoms at their contact distances spanned three tenths of one. And it peaks at the neutral rather than falling through it, because a van der Waals radius is fitted to the distance between two atoms that are not bonded and an ionic radius is one term of a sum fitted to the distance between two that are.

The surface a table draws

Three noble gases stop at a surface enclosing between 99.38 and 99.75 per cent of their density — a near-constant, and an argument that a contour is a real boundary. Charge the atoms and it collapses. Across ten electrons the tabulated radius encloses anything from 94.4 to 99.98 per cent, it peaks at the neutral rather than trending through it, and radii built at a fixed enclosure do not add up to a single measured separation.

orbitals · Contour

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Contour levelProbability densityEnclosed probabilityConventionEffective nuclear chargeNodeShieldingIsosurfaceOne-electron modelsPenetrationWavefunctionthe aufbau principle

All concepts