One-electron models — where it appears
Named by 42 essays across 7 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.
What an orbital is
Not a region the electron occupies, not a path it follows, and for any atom but hydrogen not an exact anything. An orbital is a one-electron wavefunction, and almost every difficulty in this subject comes from forgetting that.
Orbitals are not where the electron is
A many-electron atom has no exact orbitals at all. The orbital picture is a basis for an approximation — an extremely good one — and treating it as a description of reality is the source of most of the confusion in this subject.
Molecular orbital and valence bond
Two frameworks, taught as rivals, describing the same molecules. One starts from delocalised orbitals and localises; the other starts from localised bonds and delocalises. Pushed far enough they meet.
The aufbau order is not a property of the atom
Iron's 3d orbital is more than four times smaller than its 4s and, by every one-electron estimate available, far lower in energy. The 4s fills first anyway, and it empties first too — which is not a paradox but a sign that the filling order was never a list of orbital energies.
What an electron actually feels
A 3d orbital is less than half the size of the 4s beside it and fills second anyway. The charge an electron feels is not the nuclear charge, the correction is a fit rather than a derivation, and the two facts together explain the shape of the periodic table.
What a photoelectron spectrum measures
The bands of a photoelectron spectrum are routinely read off as orbital energies. They are ionisation energies, which is a different quantity — and the identification rests on two errors of about an electronvolt each that happen to have opposite signs.
What the screening model cannot see
Slater's rules put the 2s and the 2p in one group, so they give both orbitals exactly the same effective nuclear charge at every element from boron to neon. The two are separated by several electronvolts in all six, and the model has no term that could produce it.
The atom does not bring its own orbital
Build a one-electron diatomic from two hydrogen 1s functions and it comes out 25 per cent too long and 37 per cent too weakly bound. Let the molecule choose how large those functions are and the bond length is right to three figures, at an exponent of 1.238 — the orbital contracts by a quarter when the bond forms.
The hole that is not repulsion
Two electrons in a bond keep out of each other's way, and the obvious reason is that they repel. Setting the repulsion to zero and computing the spin correlation exactly gives −0.125 rather than nothing, and the number is reproduced to nine decimal places by a determinant with no repulsion in it at all.
The smallest many-electron calculation
A Hückel energy comes from a model with one electron in it. Add a single term — a cost for two electrons on the same site — and the problem stops being a matrix of size n and becomes a matrix over configurations. Four sites give thirty-six of them, which is small enough to solve exactly, and the answers correct two things the one-electron model got wrong.
A Gaussian is the wrong shape
Sixty years of molecular calculation are built on functions that get the two ends of an orbital wrong. A Gaussian has no cusp at the nucleus and dies too fast far away, and no number of them fixes either — while three of them already reproduce hydrogen's 1s to better than 99.9 per cent by overlap, and that is why the method works.
A contraction is a decision made once
Every published basis set freezes its primitive functions into fixed combinations, on an isolated atom, before any molecule is in sight. Freeing one coefficient recovers three quarters of what that costs — and freeing it at the other end of the basis recovers one per cent.
A better energy is not a better answer
The variational principle makes the energy a one-way test: lower is closer. It also makes the energy the least sensitive thing a wavefunction gets wrong — second order in the error where every other property is first — so the two diverge without limit as a calculation improves.
A slice is not the surface
The page is flat, so every printed orbital is a slice through a contour rather than the contour itself — and a curve that leaves a tenth of the density outside it in space leaves about a thirtieth outside it on the page. Both claims are true of the same picture and only one of them is ever stated.
Closer is not more overlap
Two 1s orbitals overlap more the closer they are, and every curve drawn from that pair says the same thing. Put a radial node into one of them and the rule fails: a 1s with a 2s overlaps by 0.016 at contact, by 0.282 near four bohr, and less again beyond — and two 2p orbitals head-on change sign at 5.06 bohr and are more strongly coupled at eight bohr than at four.
The orbital in momentum space
Every orbital has a second picture as complete as the first and almost never drawn. Nothing is added by taking it — it is the same function in the other variable — but the uncertainty product falls out of it, and the functions quantum chemistry is built from turn out to be the only ones that attain the bound.
A function that is already there
Adding a function to a basis set can only lower the energy, so a bigger basis is a better one. What that leaves out is that the same act makes the functions less independent: an optimised basis's smallest overlap eigenvalue halves with every function added, and a function placed on top of one already present buys less than a millionth of what a well-placed one buys while driving that eigenvalue to 4×10⁻¹⁰ — past which the calculation is refused outright.
A surface is not a count of broken bonds
Cut a crystal and every atom in the new face has lost one of its six neighbours. The standard estimate follows immediately: a surface costs one sixth of the cohesive energy per atom exposed. Computed, it costs a little over half that — the atom keeps 91.2 per cent of its binding while keeping only 83.3 per cent of its bonds, because the bonds that survive get stronger when their competitors are removed.
A third kind of correlation
The two-site model gave an exact identity — the power of the correlation energy in the repulsion equals the occupation of the bonding natural orbital — and asked whether anything like it survives with more orbitals. It does not, and the way it fails is better than the identity was: a ring of four gives a power of one where every closed-shell system gives two, at repulsions fifty times weaker than the hopping, because its reference was never a single state.
The degeneracy no group predicts
How many orbitals can share an energy is decided by a group before any energy is computed, and the rotation group of a central potential permits one, three, five and seven. Hydrogen's second shell has four orbitals at one energy and its third has nine. The extra degeneracy is not an accident of the arithmetic — it is the signature of a symmetry that has not been named, and it survives only for a potential that goes exactly as one over r.
Two bent bonds, or a σ and a π
A carbon–carbon double bond is drawn two ways and the two look like rival claims about what is there. They are one occupied space in two bases, related by a rotation of exactly forty-five degrees: the density is identical to the last bit a double holds, the bent pair are sp⁵ hybrids at 50.77° to the axis, and their charge sits 0.235 Å off the plane of the molecule where neither canonical orbital's does.
Where the states pile up
Two bands of the same width can be entirely different objects. Scale a chain, a square net and a cubic structure to one width and what is left varies by a factor of four — a chain puts more than half its levels in the outer thirds of its band and a cubic structure puts more than half in the middle third — and that difference alone decides how strongly each of them binds.
A full band is not an insulator
Two electrons per atom, two orbitals per atom, and the lower set exactly full: the count says insulator, and magnesium is a metal. The count is not wrong about the count. What it assumes is that the two sets of levels occupy separate ranges of energy, and whether they do is a comparison of four numbers that has nothing to do with how many electrons there are.
The distortion the filling chooses
A half-filled chain of equal bonds is unstable and alternates — long, short, long, short. That is the case everyone is shown, and it is one case. Fill the chain a third of the way instead and the alternation is worthless: what wins is a pattern that repeats every three bonds, and the period is one over the filling at every filling tried.
The symmetry that is not a rotation
Hydrogen's n = 2 shell holds four states at one energy and its rotation group accounts for at most three. The operator that accounts for the fourth is built here out of computed integrals: three matrices whose commutators close into the rotations, whose product with the angular momentum vanishes, and whose Casimir comes out at exactly n² − 1.
A bond is not two atoms overlapping
The surface enclosing ninety per cent of a σ orbital's density is one closed surface with both nuclei inside it, at a level of 0.0359. The two atomic surfaces usually drawn instead sit at 0.0394, are a different shape, and enclose 91.70 per cent of the same orbital — and whether the molecular one is one object or two is decided by the fraction the caption claims, anywhere between 2.1 and 5.2 ångström.
A vacancy is not an impurity
An impurity is a site whose energy has been changed, and everything about the level it produces depends on by how much. A vacancy is a site that is not there, and the levels it leaves sit at exactly zero for a reason that cannot be tuned, weakened or moved — the count of them is a difference between two numbers of atoms, and two vacancies do not split however far apart they are put.
The tenth that is not drawn
A ninety per cent contour of a hydrogen 1s orbital is a sphere of radius 2.661 bohr, and two of them stop touching at 5.322 bohr — where the overlap between the two orbitals is still 0.0768 and rising in importance. At a three-ångström contact, 36.9 per cent of the overlap integral lies outside both drawn surfaces, and holding nine tenths of it inside the picture would take a contour enclosing 97.28 per cent.
The basis the other atom lent
Two atoms in a molecule are described in each other's functions and the separated atoms are not, so the molecule is treated better than the pieces and the binding comes out too large. That is the basis set superposition error, it is removed by a standard correction, and for H₂⁺ in four Gaussians a centre it is six tenths of a microhartree against an incompleteness error of twelve millihartree — a factor of eighteen thousand the other way.
How nearly a broken symmetry survives
The hydrogen shell's extra symmetry is what makes its Stark effect linear, and a real atom does not have it. Screening splits the shell, and the field needed to overcome the splitting and restore the linear behaviour is a curve — from forty thousand volts a centimetre at a quantum defect of 0.0004 to thirty million at a defect of 0.21.
The arrangement a count cannot pick
Three arrangements of one composition came out ordered by their count of unlike bonds, which looked like a rule. Enumerating every arrangement instead of three shows it is not one: it holds at every composition on a square net at a small contrast, fails at four of them at a large contrast, and fails on a triangular net at any contrast at all.
The surface a neighbour moves
An ion in a crystal sits in the field of the ion next to it, and that field moves its contour. The displacement has a closed form, it is checked against the polarisability it implies, and it turns out to be almost perfectly anti-correlated with the discrepancy it was proposed to explain — the pairs that need the most correction get the least.
The carriers a distortion was hiding
A half-filled ring of 4m carries exactly one pair of thermal carriers at every temperature, which is true only of a ring held rigid. Allowed to move, it does not carry them: it alternates, opens a gap of 0.4927, and carries none at all until a temperature that undoes the distortion.
The chain distorts hardest where it stops
Holding the alternation uniform is what made the end energy a clean constant, and it is the one assumption the end-energy calculation had to make. Letting every bond find its own value shows the distortion is largest at the end and decays inwards over a measurable length — one and a half bonds in a strongly dimerised chain, five in a weak one.
A particle in a box the alloy made
A random alloy's gap is set by the longest run of like sites. What sits at the edge of that gap turns out to be the simplest state in quantum mechanics: a particle in a box of L sites, occupying 2(L+1)/3 of them, to within three per cent and with nothing fitted — except for the two states in forty that found a second run to share.
A bond with nothing in the middle
Two head-on 2p functions have an overlap that changes sign at 5.03 bohr, and the picture of what that means is worth drawing. Below that separation the combination the model fills has a nodal plane through the midpoint of the bond, so two electrons in it put exactly nothing between the nuclei; above it the same model fills the other one. Which picture a bonding orbital has is decided by a separation.
Two events where there was one
A broken symmetry returns at a field where the coupling matches the gap it has to overcome, and in a shell with two levels that field is a single number. The next shell up has three, two gaps and two dipoles — so there are two crossovers, a factor of 3.66 apart, both of them below the single one of the shell below, and the exponent takes more than a decade of field to travel between them.
The node that decided a picture
A hydrogenic calculation cannot say whether formaldehyde's localised description is two bent components or σ and π, because the integral that decides it came out at 0.00718 where it should be the largest in the molecule. Replacing the hydrogenic radial functions with nodeless Slater ones moves that overlap by a factor of ninety-seven, leaves the π overlap identical to the last bit, and flips the answer: the description is bent.
Three events, and a ratio of two dipoles
The m = 0 half of a shell has two crossovers because it has three levels and two coupled pairs. The other half has two levels and one, so the whole shell has three distinct fields rather than four — and two of the three share a gap exactly, which makes the ratio between them a ratio of two dipoles, 2/√3.
A filled shell is not an empty statement
A bond order of −0.954 between two orbitals with no overlap and no resonance integral invites the prediction that at six electrons — every level occupied, the sum over a complete set — it would be exactly zero. It is exactly one seventh, and the reason is that a complete set in a non-orthogonal basis sums to the inverse of the overlap matrix, which has entries where the overlap has none.
The overlap the model is not proportional to
Without a computed π overlap, the natural argument reasons about one instead: the denominator over-predicts the halide trend, so the overlap must shrink down the group to cancel part of it. Computed, it grows — 3.5 times from fluoride to chloride. And the fitted parameter changes sign across the series, which no ratio of squared overlaps can do.
A symmetry holds or it does not
One level of a three-orbital trio sits at the free-atom energy exactly, at every third-orbital energy, because the antisymmetric combination of the pair has nothing of its own symmetry to mix with. Detuning one of the two by a twentieth of an electron volt moves it by half of that — first order, immediately, with no protected regime at all.
Named alongside it
The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.
Model limitClosed formDegeneracyApproximationBasisOverlap integralEigenvalueProbability densityEffective nuclear chargeQuadratureConvergenceTight-binding models