Molecular Geometry & Bonding
what the shape decides
Concept

Canonical orbitals — where it appears

The occupied orbitals in the form that diagonalises the effective one-electron Hamiltonian. They are delocalised over the whole molecule and describe exactly the same density as any localised set obtained from them by a unitary transformation.

Named by 14 essays across 5 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

methane — Td. The molecule with the point group found from its coordinates rather than looked up: every candidate operation was applied and kept when it permuted the atoms among themselves.

Hybridisation does not explain

Methane's photoelectron spectrum has two bands, not one. Four equivalent sp³ bonding orbitals cannot produce that, and the resolution is that hybridisation was never a claim about what a measurement would find.

wrong · Hybrids Four bonds, or one a₁ and three t₂. The same four occupied orbitals written in two bases. On the left each orbital sits on one bond; on the right one is shared over all four hydrogens and three follow the Cartesian directions. The transformation between them is orthogonal, so the density is unchanged.

The localisation transformation, demonstrated

Four equivalent bonds or one a₁ and three t₂ — two descriptions of methane's bonding electrons that disagree about everything except the electron density, which they agree about to the last bit a double can hold.

bonding · Hybrids methane: 2 valence bands. The measured valence photoelectron bands of methane, each labelled with the symmetry species of the orbital it comes from, and beside them the species the valence basis spans — the central atom's s and p functions and one s on each ligand, reduced in the molecule's own group. A band carrying a species the reduction does not produce would stop this figure being drawn.

What a photoelectron spectrum measures

The bands of a photoelectron spectrum are routinely read off as orbital energies. They are ionisation energies, which is a different quantity — and the identification rests on two errors of about an electronvolt each that happen to have opposite signs.

wrong · Photoelectron water: 4 valence bands. The measured valence photoelectron bands of water, each labelled with the symmetry species of the orbital it comes from, and beside them the species the valence basis spans — the central atom's s and p functions and one s on each ligand, reduced in the molecule's own group. A band carrying a species the reduction does not produce would stop this figure being drawn.

Water's lone pairs are not a pair

Every course draws two equivalent lone pairs on water, pointing away from the hydrogens like a pair of ears. Its photoelectron spectrum shows the two bands they would produce at 12.6 and 14.7 electronvolts, two point one apart, in different symmetry species.

bonding · Photoelectron ammonia: 3 valence bands. The measured valence photoelectron bands of ammonia, each labelled with the symmetry species of the orbital it comes from, and beside them the species the valence basis spans — the central atom's s and p functions and one s on each ligand, reduced in the molecule's own group. A band carrying a species the reduction does not produce would stop this figure being drawn.

Fewer bands than electrons

Methane has eight valence electrons and two photoelectron bands. Ammonia has eight and three; water has eight and four. The count is not of electrons, not of bonds and not of orbitals — it is of the symmetry species the occupied orbitals fall into, and it falls as the symmetry rises.

spectra · Photoelectron One carbon, three lithiums, and no way to make it two. The four localised orbitals of the tetramer, with the share of each pair on each of the eight framework atoms. Each sits on exactly four: one carbon and the three lithiums of the face that carbon caps, which was not put in anywhere. The four shares are not equal — about 59 per cent of the pair is on the carbon — so the participation number comes out near 2.5 rather than at four. A bond over four centres is not a bond divided into four.

Four centres, and the pair that will not localise

The occupied orbitals of a molecule can be mixed freely without changing anything observable, and the freedom is usually spent on making them as local as possible. For the methyllithium tetramer the answer is four centres — one carbon and the three lithiums of the face it caps — and no mixing of the four pairs reduces it.

beyond · Multicentre How many centres, by two measures that do not agree. For each of eight systems, the number of atoms one localised pair has real amplitude on, and its participation number — which weights those atoms by how much of the pair each holds. Where the sharing is even the two coincide; where it is not they differ by more than a whole centre, and that gap is what electron deficiency looks like from the inside. one of the systems has more than one localisation, so for it neither number is an answer.

One scale, from two centres to a cage

How many centres a pair of electrons holds together is two different numbers, and they separate exactly where the bonding is most deficient: the methyllithium tetramer's pairs sit on four atoms each and have a participation number of 2.54. Run the same measurement up the scale and the twelve-vertex borane refuses it — its localisation has at least ten maxima differing by six parts in a thousand, so the number of centres is not an output for it at all.

beyond · Multicentre Three bent bonds, at a hundred and one degrees to each other. A carbon–carbon triple bond in its localised description: three equivalent bent bonds, spaced by 101.54 degrees, each tilted 63.43 degrees off the axis and each carrying 0.17 of an s orbital — an sp⁵ hybrid. Its charge sits 0.32 ångström off the axis, where every canonical orbital's sits on it. The mixing that makes the three equivalent is a rotation in the three-dimensional occupied space, so the density is untouched.

Three bent bonds, and the same hybrid

A triple bond localises into three bent bonds at 101.537 degrees to one another, each an sp⁵ hybrid with exactly one sixth s character. A double bond's two bent components are sp⁵ hybrids at 101.537 degrees. The two are the same hybrid, built out of different frameworks and in different numbers, and the reason is that a third of a half is a half of a third.

shape · Hybrids Ten answers, and none of them is another one turned round. Every localised description the search found for a twelve-vertex cage, placed by the value of the functional it maximises. There are 10 of them, spanning 0.02, and the two closest differ by 0 — far more than the 10⁻¹³ the sweep converges to, so they are different maxima rather than one maximum reached to different precision. Each has its own multiset of participation numbers, and a symmetry of the cage permutes sites without changing that multiset, so no two of these are related by one. The controls above find one answer each.

How many descriptions a cage has

A localisation is a maximisation, and running it once reports the maximum it reached rather than the maximum there is. Run to exhaustion on a twelve-vertex borane it finds ten answers and then three batches of twelve starts in a row that find nothing new — and none of the ten is another one seen from a different side, because a symmetry of the cage cannot change a multiset of participation numbers and all ten multisets differ.

beyond · Multicentre Four bonds, or one a₁ and three t₂. The same four occupied orbitals written in two bases. On the left each orbital sits on one bond; on the right one is shared over all four hydrogens and three follow the Cartesian directions. The transformation between them is orthogonal, so the density is unchanged.

The answer a search is most likely to give

If a cage has ten equally good localised descriptions, why does the literature agree about its picture? The hoped-for answer was that one basin is very large. Counting four hundred and eighty starting points says it is not: two independent searches agree one time in ten, and the description they most often return is not the best one.

beyond · Multicentre The hybrids do not point at the atoms. For each cycloalkane, the angle between its two ring hybrids — fixed by orthogonality once the measured H–C–H angle has said how much s character the hydrogens take — against the angle between its carbons. Cyclopropane's differ by 45.5°, so each hybrid points 22.75° outside the bond it makes; cyclohexane's agree to 0.035°, which is the control.

The hybrids that point outside the bonds

Coulson's relation says two equivalent hybrids sharing an s orbital are orthogonal only between ninety and a hundred and eighty degrees. Cyclopropane's carbons make sixty, so its ring hybrids cannot point at the atoms they bond to — and the same relation says by how much they miss: 22.75 degrees each, falling to 0.03 in cyclohexane.

bonding · Hybrids The count is a curve, and the curve flattens. How many distinct localised descriptions of a twelve-vertex cage had been found after each batch, out of 4,000 random starts. The last new one appears at start 124; the remaining 3,876 add nothing. The dashed curve is what the basin sizes measured here predict — the chance of having hit each description at least once — and it is a closed form rather than a fit to the points.

Where the count stops being an effort

A cage's localised descriptions were counted by a search that stopped when it stopped finding new ones, which makes the count a property of the stopping rule. Run to four thousand starts the count is fourteen and the last new description appears at start 124 — after which three thousand eight hundred and seventy-six starts add nothing. The four rarest are found six times in a thousand, which is what says nothing rarer is hiding.

beyond · Multicentre Three basin populations from one search. The share of 4000 random starts landing on each localised description, in rank order, on a logarithmic axis, for three cages and fillings. a twelve-vertex cage at twelve electrons gives 14 descriptions and two groups with a gap; a nine-vertex cage at eight electrons gives 63 descriptions and a smooth tail; a twelve-vertex cage at twenty electrons gives 15 descriptions and one basin and dust. Only the first is the twelve-vertex shape, and the rule it suggests is a rule about that shape.

Three shapes from one search

A cage's fourteen localised descriptions fell into two groups with a factor of five between them and nothing in the gap, which made counting the big basins look like a stopping rule. Two more cases from the same family give a smooth tail over sixty-three descriptions and a single basin holding ninety-eight per cent. One search, one family, three shapes.

beyond · Multicentre What a rotation group buys over a single angle. The Boys functional at the canonical orbitals, at the best mixing of the two bonds with the lone pair left alone, and at the maximum over the whole three-dimensional rotation group. The first step is 11.70 per cent and the second, which no two-orbital treatment can reach, is a further 2.50.

An interior maximum a third orbital allows

Two orbitals related by a mirror plane give a Boys functional with no linear term, so it has no interior maximum and no angle is ever searched for. Add the oxygen lone pair and the search over a three-dimensional rotation group finds one — eight and a half degrees of lone pair mixed into two bent bonds, worth a further two and a half per cent that no pair of orbitals could reach.

bonding · Hybrids

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Unitary transformationLocalisationModel limitBasisLocal minimumClosed formDegeneracyElectron-deficient bondingIonisation energyMulticentre bondingParticipation ratioCluster

All concepts