Molecular Geometry & Bonding
what the shape decides
Concept

Insulator — where it appears

A structure with a gap between its filled and empty levels that survives the limit of infinite size. Band theory attributes it to a filled band; repulsion can open one where band theory says there cannot be one.

Named by 7 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A half-filled ring's cheapest excitation goes to zero. The energy of the smallest available excitation of a half-filled ring, against the number of atoms, on log axes. Every doubling at least halves it, so in the limit there is no smallest excitation — which is what a metal is, before any band picture is drawn.

What a metal actually is

Not shiny, not a good conductor, not an element on the left of the table. A metal is a system with excitations of arbitrarily small energy, and that definition can be checked on a sequence of finite rings without drawing a band diagram or mentioning conduction at all.

solids · Metal The gap against size: uniform against δ = 0.15. The HOMO–LUMO gap of a half-filled chain plotted against the number of sites, on log axes, for a uniform chain and for one whose bonds alternate. The uniform sequence falls without limit; the alternating one settles at four times the alternation.

The gap is not the band width

Two numbers describe a band and they answer different questions. The width is set by how many neighbours an atom has; the gap is set by how unequal they are. A structure can have a wide band and no gap, a narrow band and a large one, and changing one leaves the other alone.

solids · Peierls distortion benzene — D6h. The molecule with the point group found from its coordinates rather than looked up: every candidate operation was applied and kept when it permuted the atoms among themselves.

Counting electrons in an extended structure

The octet rule, Hückel's 4n + 2 and the 8 − N rule that predicts the structures of the main-group elements are one rule counted three ways. Each says the same thing — close the shell — and each stops being reliable at exactly the point where closing it becomes impossible.

solids · Metal 60 electrons in 60 levels. The density of states of a ring of 60, drawn with the energy up the page, and the 60 electrons filled in from the bottom. Where the filling stops is what decides whether the system has cheap excitations.

A half-filled band is not always a metal

Every band picture rests on an approximation that a whole class of materials refuses — each electron moving in an average field, never seeing another one individually. Where the repulsion is strong enough, a half-filled band describes an insulator, and no amount of care with the band fixes it.

wrong · Metal A gap where band theory says there cannot be one. The exact charge gap of a half-filled four-site ring against the on-site repulsion, with the one-electron gap of the same ring beneath it. The one-electron answer is zero at every U — the ring's half-filled shell is degenerate — while the exact gap reaches 5.99t.

The insulator band theory cannot see

A half-filled ring of four sites has a degenerate shell and no gap at all in the one-electron picture, which is the definition of a metal at that size. Its exact charge gap is zero when the electrons do not repel and grows without limit when they do — so a material can have a half-filled band and not conduct, and here is the number.

solids · Metal How many sites a state occupies, and whether that depends on the ring. The participation ratio of the states at the middle of the band — the number of sites a state occupies — against the width of the disorder, for rings of 50, 100, 200 sites. With no disorder the three curves are three different numbers, each two thirds of its own ring. At the right they have converged: 7.47 sites on a ring of 50 and 9.82 on a ring 4 times larger.

The third way to be an insulator

A ring of two hundred sites with a half-filled band has its levels crowding together as 1/n, which is the usual electronic-structure criterion for a metal, and it goes on holding at every disorder tested. Meanwhile the states at the middle of the band go from occupying 127 sites to occupying 10 — and at that disorder the number stops depending on how large the ring is at all.

wrong · Metal How many times more a metal carries, and when. The ratio of the carriers in a uniform ring to those in an alternating one of the same size, at four sizes and six temperatures. Down the left-hand column the two are indistinguishable, because a ring of 42 at kT = 0.002 has a level spacing larger than the temperature and is no more a metal than the gapped one is. Along the bottom row they are indistinguishable again, because the temperature is larger than the gap. The word only means anything in the middle.

The metal a thermometer cannot find

A metal is a system with excitations of arbitrarily small energy, which is a claim about a sequence of finite systems rather than about any one of them. Put a temperature on it and the claim needs a second limit, and the two do not commute: a uniform ring of forty-two at kT = 0.002 carries exactly as much as an alternating one, and at kT = 0.1 a ring of three hundred and twenty-two carries only four times as much.

wrong · Metal

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

MetalBands in a solidFillingConductivityFermi levelHOMO–LUMO gapLevel spacingClosed-shell configurationsCoordination numberDensity of statesEigenvalueElectron correlation

All concepts