Molecular Geometry & Bonding
what the shape decides
Concept

Charge density — where it appears

The distribution of electronic charge through space, which is an observable. Dividing it between atoms is not: every scheme for doing so is a convention, and the conventions disagree.

Named by 10 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Hückel levels of three-centre four-electron. The orbital energies of the pi system, computed as the eigenvalues of the molecule's adjacency matrix. Degenerate levels share a line. The electrons are placed by aufbau with Hund's rule, so a half-filled degenerate shell shows as two unpaired spins.

Three-centre bonding, computed

Three orbitals in a line and four electrons: a bonding level, a level with exactly zero amplitude on the central atom, and an empty antibonding one. The middle atom never exceeds an octet, and the ligands carry the charge — which is why every molecule that needs this arrangement has electronegative ligands.

beyond · Hypervalency π bond orders in naphthalene. Each bond drawn with a thickness set by its computed pi bond order, and the number printed beside it. The orders come from the eigenvectors and cost nothing extra once the matrix is diagonalised.

Bond order from the eigenvectors

Having diagonalised the matrix, the coefficients are already there. Two sums over them give every bond's order and every atom's charge, and naphthalene's three kinds of bond come out in the order the measurements find them.

bonding · Delocalisation pyrrole against cyclopentadienyl anion. The Hückel levels of pyrrole beside those of cyclopentadienyl anion, which is the same graph with one diagonal entry and the bonds touching it changed. The parent's levels are symmetric about α because its matrix has nothing on the diagonal; the substituted system's are not, and the asymmetry is the size of the fitted parameter rather than a result.

Six electrons in a ring that is not all carbon

Pyrrole and the cyclopentadienyl anion hold the same six π electrons in the same five-membered ring. The anion spreads them perfectly evenly; pyrrole's nitrogen keeps 1.720 of them and furan's oxygen keeps 1.791 — the more electronegative atom donates less, and the bond orders to it fall with it.

beyond · Delocalisation pyridine against benzene. The Hückel levels of pyridine beside those of benzene, which is the same graph with one diagonal entry and the bonds touching it changed. The parent's levels are symmetric about α because its matrix has nothing on the diagonal; the substituted system's are not, and the asymmetry is the size of the fitted parameter rather than a result.

Hückel with a heteroatom

A hydrocarbon's Hückel matrix contains no fitted number at all. Put one nitrogen in the ring and two arrive at once, the levels stop being symmetric about α, and the delocalisation energy stops being quotable — all from changing three entries in a matrix.

bonding · Delocalisation The moment that does not depend on where the origin is. For each molecule, the dipole and the largest quadrupole component about the centre, and the same two about an origin moved 1.6 bohr away. The lowest non-vanishing moment is unchanged in every row and the one above it moves in every row. The 4 non-polar molecules here have a quadrupole that is a property of the molecule; the polar ones have one that is a property of a choice.

What a dipole cannot tell apart

A dipole moment is three numbers extracted from a whole charge distribution, and enormously many distributions give the same three. The moment above it is not even a property of the molecule unless the one below it vanishes — which is why a quadrupole is quoted with an origin and a dipole is not.

shape · Dipole Orbitals at the 90 per cent contour. Several orbitals drawn at the same enclosed fraction and, unless stated otherwise, at the same scale — so the sizes on the page are the sizes. Each contour was solved for separately by integrating that orbital's own density. Contours drawn: 2px at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 9.49e-3; 2py at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 9.49e-3; 2pz at 90% of its density, |ψ| = 9.48e-3.

A filled shell has no shape

Sum the angular densities of a complete p shell and the answer is 3/4π in every direction, to sixteen decimal places. A filled d shell gives 5/4π. The lobes are in the decomposition and not in the density, and nothing that measures a closed-shell atom can see them.

orbitals · Contour One carbon, three lithiums, and no way to make it two. The four localised orbitals of the tetramer, with the share of each pair on each of the eight framework atoms. Each sits on exactly four: one carbon and the three lithiums of the face that carbon caps, which was not put in anywhere. The four shares are not equal — about 59 per cent of the pair is on the carbon — so the participation number comes out near 2.5 rather than at four. A bond over four centres is not a bond divided into four.

Four centres, and the pair that will not localise

The occupied orbitals of a molecule can be mixed freely without changing anything observable, and the freedom is usually spent on making them as local as possible. For the methyllithium tetramer the answer is four centres — one carbon and the three lithiums of the face it caps — and no mixing of the four pairs reduces it.

beyond · Multicentre Face to face repels, edge to face attracts. Two benzene molecules 5 Å apart, one turned against the other, with only the quadrupole interaction between them. Stacked, the two negative faces meet and the energy is +8.8 kJ/mol; perpendicular, one molecule's positive rim meets the other's negative face and it is -4.6. The sign changes on the way, so the preference is not that one arrangement is weaker — it is that they are opposite. This is a molecule with no dipole moment at all.

Zero dipole is not no interaction

Benzene's dipole moment is exactly zero at every origin, and its quadrupole moment is large enough to decide a crystal structure. Two benzenes face to face repel by nine kilojoules a mole; edge to face they attract, and the sign changes on the way between.

shape · Dipole Where the orphan pair actually sits. A σ-only Hückel model of each molecule, built from its own coordinates: the central atom's four valence orbitals, one σ orbital on each ligand, and the coupling between them the direction cosine of that ligand. Lone pairs need no special handling — they come out of the diagonalisation as the central orbitals no ligand combination transforms like. The charge is measured rather than assigned, and PF₅ comes out with two kinds of fluorine at 3 at -0.13 and 2 at -0.3, the more charged pair being the axial one that carries the orphan.

The count is the population

The census counted how many ligand combinations have no partner on the central atom and called the count n + L − 4. A σ-only model built from each molecule's own coordinates says what that count is worth: with no electronegativity difference anywhere, the mean charge on a ligand is minus the orphan count divided by the ligand count, exactly, in all ten cases. And the prediction the census made — that the charge grows with the orphan count — is refused by the divisor.

beyond · Hypervalency A ninety per cent surface with a neighbour beside it. The contour enclosing 90 per cent of a one-electron ion's density at an effective charge of 1.6, drawn with no field as a circle and in a field of 0.05 atomic units as the closed curve. The surface moves out by 47.3 millibohr on the side the field pulls the density towards and in by the same amount on the far side — 2.84 per cent of its own radius. What the sphere encloses does not change to first order; only where the surface is does.

The surface a neighbour moves

An ion in a crystal sits in the field of the ion next to it, and that field moves its contour. The displacement has a closed form, it is checked against the polarisability it implies, and it turns out to be almost perfectly anti-correlated with the discrepancy it was proposed to explain — the pairs that need the most correction get the least.

orbitals · Contour

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

ElectronegativityBenzeneBond orderDelocalisationDipole momentHückel theoryPartial chargeClosed-shell configurationsConjugationContour levelConventionEigenvector

All concepts